Welcome to Sandy's Pizza
Sandy's Pizza, located at 609 S Main St in Fort Branch, Indiana, offers a delightful dining experience steeped in nostalgia. The restaurant's warm ambiance features gas oil and farm decor, creating a cozy atmosphere for guests. Known for its delicious pizza and wings, Sandy’s takes pride in quality over quantity, evident during their popular Sunday buffet, where a limited selection of pizzas shines with exceptional flavors. Patrons rave about the friendly service, though it remains crucial for staff assistance during busy times. With its commitment to taste and a welcoming vibe, Sandy’s Pizza is a beloved local gem perfect for any occasion.
Sandy's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Great pizza and wings. Nice atmosphere. Gas oil and farm decor.
The food is amazing, but the waitress Aubrey is a rock star!! My wife and I came up on a Friday night and Aubrey was the only waitress; even though there was probably 10 other employees in the kitchen. It was extremely busy and not one person from the kitchen attempted to help with the dining room floor! Granted they may of not been trained to wait on tables, however taking a drink order, cleaning a table, would have helped Aubrey tremendously!
Picked up the 36 inch pizzas for our son's birthday. The pizzas were ready on time and very good. Third year in a row we've come from Illinois to celebrate his birthday with Sandy's pizza.
Great local pizza restaurant. The restaurant itself is decorated with nostalgic Americana themes. We came here for the Sunday buffet. Due to the smaller size of the restaurant, the selection of pizza was limited. What it lacked in variety, it made up for in quality and taste. Included in the adult buffet is even one beer or wine. They had dessert pizza (Apple) and soft serve ice cream. Definitely recommend.
My parents first time here they loved it. Good as always thanx guys!
I’m definitely not a pizza fan but I do have to say I almost always eat Sandys pizza I love the combination pizza loaded with the sweet red peppers and my kids love the all meat pizza it’s just something about the sweet pizza sauce also that makes it so delicious we also love the wings they are so delicious! If we have time we love to dine in the Elvis booth my sons idol is Elvis he’s been singing Elvis songs since he was 12 they have a nice atmosphere inside I could look at all their items on the walls every time we go in to eat!!
Great Pizza with plenty of options. We always get the combination pizza. The sweet red peppers and root beer are both must! There's a lot of neat vintage memorabilia hanging on the walls. Perhaps you will want to eat at the Elvis booth or maybe the Blues Brothers.
Great atmosphere and even greater pizza. I ordered the all meat with the "sweet reds" (red peppers) and it was delicious. The crust was thin and crispy and the pizza was baked to perfection. Being from out of town and eating our local pizza, this is definitely a nice change from our usual pizza. Sandy's is a place you should give a try, because you'll come back often. Oh, and our server was excellent too. Her recommendations for the pizzas we ordered made a huge difference.
Location
-
609 S Main St, Fort Branch, IN 47648, United States Hotline: +1 812-753-3972
Welcome to Sandy's Pizza, a beloved local gem nestled at 609 S Main St, Fort Branch, IN. Known for its great pizza and wings, Sandy's Pizza creates an inviting atmosphere that resonates with the charm of Americana. With its rustic gas oil and farm decor, diners are transported to a cozy, nostalgic space—a perfect backdrop for enjoying a hearty meal.
The menu shines with options like their famous 36-inch pizzas, which are not only a feast for the eyes but also delightfully flavorful. Regular patron Jeanne Wright noted that her family travels annually from Illinois to celebrate special occasions with Sandy's, a testament to the restaurant’s dedication to quality and taste. This commitment is echoed by Kelly Rymer, who emphasized that even first-time visitors will leave with wonderful memories and satisfied palates.
Another highlight is the Sunday buffet, where the selection may be limited due to the restaurant's smaller size, yet it’s the quality that truly stands out. Customers have praised the deliciousness of the pies and even the delightful dessert pizza choices, like the apple variety. A lovely touch is that the adult buffet includes a complimentary beer or wine, enhancing the dining experience.
Live service can be hit or miss, as noted in Wayne Opel’s review, where he applauded the exceptional performance of waitress Aubrey during a busy night. Such dedication amidst a bustling environment illustrates the passion the staff has for providing a memorable dining experience. While teamwork could improve behind the scenes, the heartwarming service does shine through.
If you’re looking to indulge in delicious pizza surrounded by a warm atmosphere that feels like home, look no further than Sandy's Pizza. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this restaurant promises a flavorful slice of Fort Branch life.
For further details, Sandy's Pizza can be reached at +1 812-753-3972. Come and experience the magic!